By Gerrino J. Saunders
Journal Staff Writer
As The Bahamas moves to reform its tax system to survive in the global financial
system, new laws were passed this week in the lower chamber of parliament. It comes
from advice of key international organizations like the Inter-American Development
Bank and should, at least for the meantime, satisfy other big financial entities like the
Organization for Economic Development (OECD).
The new tax will apply only to foreign entities in The Bahamas whose earnings
exceed $800 million annually.
The opposition agreed with the government’s move to implement the Domestic
Minimum Top-up Tax Bill, 2024 (Top-up Tax) (DMTT) which is projected to
generate revenues of up to $140 million annually.
Prime Minister Philip Davis speaking directly to the merits of the bill in its second
reading in the House of Assembly described it as being “transformative” and one that
will assist the government in carrying out its “people-focused” agenda.
The Top-up Tax is the first-ever corporate income tax introduced in The Bahamas and
is expected to raise government revenues without negatively impacting Bahamian
businesses.
Reassuring Bahamians that they will not be subjected to the provisions of this new
tax, the prime minister said, “for those who are not sure what this new tax is all about,
the first thing you should know is the Domestic Minimum Top-up Tax applies only to
multinational corporations operating in The Bahamas that earn over 750 Million
Euros per year (USD 800 million). If you do not own a multinational entity making
750 million Euros per year or more, which is the equivalent of $800 million per year
or more, this tax does not apply to you. I wanted to make that clear to those who may
have heard that the government was implementing a new tax but did not know who
would be impacted.”
Mr. Davis reminded that his administration has pledged not to introduce any major
new taxes to place a further burden on the Bahamian people, noting that his
administration has reduced taxes on a wide range of items over the past three years
including on food and construction items as well as real property tax where the
threshold to pay was increased from $250,000 to $300,000 tax free.
He said Top-up Tax Bill represents another avenue for generating significant revenues
that will be realised without placing a burden on Bahamians.
He explained, “in introducing this tax on multinational entities, we are taking part in a
major global change, as 140 other countries have signed up in agreement with the
Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) on a global
minimum corporate tax.”
“The agreement calls for a 15% tax on the turnover of multinationals for the fiscal
period beginning 1 January 2024 – although some companies may apply for an
extension until 2025 if they are newly impacted by this tax.
“The 15% is actually a reference to the total effective tax rate, which requires
corporations that don’t currently have a total 15% tax rate to “top up” with this tax to
meet the 15% mark,” Mr. Davis explained.
He said the OECD has pushed for this global movement as a part of its efforts to
prevent corporations from moving to low-tax jurisdictions while making most of their
revenues elsewhere.
Mr. Davis said, “the OECD argues that this change will produce a more fair global tax
regime, because it opens the door for hundreds of billions in revenues for jurisdictions
in which these corporations are based. Of course, there are some concerns about the
fairness of these universal standards. As this discussion evolves, The Bahamas is very
present and active in shaping the dialogue.”
The Prime Minister reminded members of the House that the government has already
helped to ensure that the United Nations (UN) plays a bigger role in shaping global
taxation and transparency efforts.
He noted Attorney General Ryan Pinder sits on the UN committee charged with
ensuring the fair application of standards.
He said, “This underscores the importance of our international advocacy. If we
weren’t present to boldly state our perspectives on these issues, we would not have the
opportunity to actively shape conversations today. Our advocacy could not have come
at a better time.”
The Global Minimum Top-Up Tax is part of a wider slate of reforms, referred to as
the Global Anti-Base Erosion Model Rules (or GLoBE rules), to prevent practices like
profit shifting and end the perpetual “race to the bottom” to lower corporate tax rates
in many jurisdictions, which ultimately benefits multinationals more than the
countries they are based in.
Mr. Davis described the initiative as “the most comprehensive global undertaking of
its kind ever attempted”.
He said it is expected that more standards will be introduced thanks to the efforts of
his administration as they will be present in the room when key decisions are being
made and new standards are being crafted and debated.
The prime minister said his administration made the decision to introduce the
Domestic Minimum Top-Up Tax for several key reasons.
He said, “first of all, as a matter of fairness, given the high levels of revenue generated
by these multinationals, it seems appropriate that the Bahamian people would benefit.
The $140 million in projected government revenues will go a long way toward further
strengthening the government’s fiscal situation and funding key programmes to
empower and support Bahamians.
“In fact, if we refuse to implement a Domestic Minimum Top-Up Tax, the annual
turnover of these multinational entities in The Bahamas would eventually be taxed by
other Jurisdictions. This would rob us of the opportunity for our people to benefit
from the presence of these corporations.”
“This Bill ensures that we capture this important source of revenue. We must also
ensure that The Bahamas, as a leading financial services jurisdiction, remains fully
compliant with global standards. This is critical because investors want to do business
in compliant jurisdictions,” said the Prime Minister.
According to Prime Minister Davis the Top-up Tax Bill was also developed to bring
The Bahamas into full compliance with international financial laws.
He said, “we have demonstrated time and time again the seriousness with which we
pursue compliance. It will never be said that The Bahamas does not make every effort
possible to remain fully compliant. Earlier this year, we were removed from the EU’s
blacklist of non-cooperative tax havens after we corrected the mess left behind by the
previous administration in rolling out a proper economic substance reporting portal
and process that met international standards.”
Mr. Davis said the government must now be proactive in ensuring that The Bahamas
remains off of any additional blacklists.
He said, “compliance is a key cornerstone of our financial services industry that we
are keen to maintain. After a lengthy public consultation process, it is clear that
industry observers support our approach and have agreed with our determination that
the introduction of this tax will not have a negative impact on our financial services
industry, especially given the fact that it is a uniform global standard. We shall remain
competitive.”
Page 5 of 6
Mr. Davis said public consultation has been critical throughout the process and that all
stakeholders have been deeply involved in giving direct feedback, analysing the
impact of the changes, and ensuring that the government has a strong draft
legislation.
Prime Minister Davis said his administration also wanted to make it clear that its
intentions were in adhering to the OECD’s standards by forecasting a target tax rate
which aligns with the global minimum.
He said, “we’ve also made it clear that there will be no further domestic income tax
policy changes made that will have a foreseeable impact on affected corporations.”
Additionally, he said multinational corporations have been equipped with the
information they need to facilitate a smooth transition to comply with the new law
which requires changes to company accounting and tax management processes that
may require resource and manpower additions.
He said as a result of the government being proactive in its approach it has give those
companies the time they need and will also give the government time to prepare for
this major change.
In conclusion Prime Minister Davis acknowledged that the Top-up Tax Bill is a
“significant” legislative and regulatory reform that will require “unprecedented”
monitoring and tax administration capabilities.
He noted, “There are a number of changes that must be made systemically. We don’t
have a history of an income tax of this kind. It is a steep departure from the business
licence fees we typically charge. It requires taking into account a wide array of
information like specific expense types that we do not currently apply our tax
administration and monitoring efforts toward.”
According to the Prime Minister significant capacity building is taking place within
the government as it moves forward with its agenda.